Re: Landrigan Chat - Dursban
Environmental Health Network
Welcome to today's chat about Dursban. I would expect that we will begin shortly.
All we need now is our featured guest and we are ready to go. Anyone that has preliminary questions, please feel free
to throw them out at any time.
Sue, what do you do at your non-profit forpesticide alternatives and hazards education?
Welcome Dr. Landrigan.
We try to get organizations to commit to using alternatives and then research what alternatives are available.
I am glad that you found time in your hectic schedule to join us today.
Dr. Landrigan has approximately 30 minutes to help us understand Dursban and the effects of chlorpyrifos on the
human body and our environment. Anyone with a specific question should feel free to fire away.
I am pleased to be here today. Philip Landrigan
What are the effects on children's health that are of
Are they endocrine disrupters?
Our local PTA has been working on grassroots
efforts to minimize the use of all pesticides in our school district.
Dursban was the pesticide of choice for a number of years. How do we document that the children who are sick, got sick from the exposure to Dursban which was sprayed once a month in their often windowless schools?
I have children who were poisoned by Dursban, is there anything I can do now to counter act the poisoning?
These are all great questions. Keep in mind that
Dr. Landrigan only has two hands and it is still early in the morning.
I am sure that he will address all of your concerns promptly.
asthma is the leading cause of admission of American
children to hospital. environmental factors make an important
contribution to causation. cancer is the second leading cause of death in American children after injuries. again environmental
factors contribute. developmental disabilities are a third category of concern
. The best way to document that Dursban is present in
schools is (1) to obtain records on how much Dursban is applied in the school, (2) to do actual measurements of Dursban in samples of either
air or dust from the school.
In response to Sue Carroll, the best way to counteract
Dursban poisoning is to restrict use of the compound and thus prevent
> What will it take to get Dursban banned?
> Dr. Landrigan, Are you familiar with Professor Abo
Donia's (sp?) work with a new test to determine organophosphate
poisoning years later?
Nancy, a group of 12 scientists including myself have
recently written to the Administrator of EPA asking that she take strong action against Dursban on two fronts: (1) to apply the full
third tenfold safety factor for agricultural use, and (2) to ban all residential use including use in homes, schools, and daycare centers
and other institutions frequented by children.
We know Dursban was used thru records, however we
have been denied samples from the schools. That still will not help us to link. They (administration) admits use, but we are having trouble
establishing cause and effect. Are you aware of the recent research by Dr. Clemente
Furlong that explains that the parent chemical of certain
organophosphate, including Dursban and diazinon are activated into the
toxic oxone form in the body. Additionally his research shows that
newborns have very low levels of PON 1 enzyme that cuts these
pesticides and even then, it is possible that they will fall into the
class of individuals that have low PON1 levels for their entire lives.
I am asking because I have copies of his research and will be happy to
mail copies to any interested person. After reading the about the
research, one could say that to expose newborns to these pesticides is
I'm new to online chats last two comments unassigned were from me.
Veronika, to make the link and document that children
in schools actually became sick as a result of exposure to Dursban, it will be necessary that a physician obtain samples of blood and urine
from these children immediately at the time of their acute illness.
The blood samples need to be tested for levels of the enzyme acetyl
cholinesterase and the urine samples tested for chlorpyrifos
Don't worry, Veronika, the program automatically names your comments - there's no need for you to write your name
before your comment.
Cynthia, you are quite correct that newborns have
extremely low levels of the enzyme that detoxifies organophosphates.
For that reason organophosphates persist in the bloodstream of newborn infants many times longer than in the bloodstream of an adult and therefore, can cause more toxic injury.
Cynthia, I would be very interested in receiving the research. Sue Lets talk later, OK?
I would like a copy as well . We could not wait for the Federal Government to
restrict Dursban. In 1997 Montgomery County Maryland stopped using Dursban (and other toxic pesticides and went to a
Marcia, part of your sentence was cut off?
That will be fine. Dr. Furlong just sent me a packet
of his papers that I'm having copied today. He has more that are being
reviewed now, that he will be forwarding later. Please e-mail me your
addresses. I'm new to this chatting ...and I don't want to lose you.
Dr. Landrigan, is there a link between Dursban and
neurodegenerative disorders like Parkinson's Dr. Landrigan, Not many people know what tests to do to
determine cholinesterase - including doctors. Is there any effort to educate Doctors and parents. If parents know and test, it seems schools would be less likely to use these products.
continued - in 1997 Montgomery County, MD stopped using
Dursban and other toxic pesticides and went to a strict IPM program-
Dursban had been used everywhere - including day care centers. For
more information call Jeff Marks 240-777-60009. In 1991 Dr.
continued - correction phone Jeff Marks - 240-777-6009
to get a copy of contract.
Our biggest problem since this began for us is that
doctors don't know or think to test for pesticide poisoning...are there any efforts in include these types of tests for children that present with health issues
> Gloria, recent evidence from newborn laboratory animals indicates that low doses of chlorpyrifos can cause loss of brain cells, and this loss of brain cells results in developmental retardation in the baby animals. We strongly suspect that these data have implications for human development but whether it translates to long-term effects like Parkinson's Disease is unknown at this time. In light of this new information about the impact of chlorpyrifos on the developing brain, it would certainly appear prudent to minimize exposure of pregnant women and newborn infants to
> Sue, if doctors need information on this point they should contact Dr. Robert Amler of CDC in Atlanta at 404-639-0700. he has set up a national network of pediatric environmental health referral centers which physicians are invited to contact.
> Why does action take twenty plus years? It was in 1991 that Dr. Sherman first wrote about the dangers of
Dursban. Veronika, you are correct that many physicians have not been trained to think about pesticide poisoning. However, the American Academy of Pediatrics has begun educational programs to counteract this problem and in November 1999 the Academy published a "Handbook of Pediatric Environmental Health" which is now available to all pediatricians in North America.
I know you deal mostly with children but shouldn't we all be concerned about exposure to these pesticides?
This book tells physicians to not take parents seriously if they question their schools environment. I was very disappointed by
many statements in this book.
Marcia, regulatory action takes many years because it almost always involves differences of opinion between parties with
opposing views. It has taken nearly 100 years to deal with the problem of lead paint poisoning. It has taken 50 years to deal with the problem of asbestos. This is the slow nature of democracy but as Winston Churchill said, democracy is much better than the alternative.
How can we help to get DURSBAN BANNED?
Sue, the AAP Handbook is certainly not perfect but it is light years ahead of anything that existed previously. As one of the co-authors, I disagree strongly with your statement that it advises pediatricians not to take parents seriously. We have always taught our pediatricians that a diagnosis of environmentally related disease begins with the doctor obtaining a careful history of exposure and of symptoms from the parent(s).
> Dr. Landrigan ...in regard to chlorpyrifos and exposure to newborns and pregnant women ...what about other organophosphate exposures to newborns and pregnant women. I'm asking because of reading Dr. Furlong's research.
Dr. Landrigan, What do you think about the development of multiple chemical sensitivity after Dursban exposure?
> Yes, it does take a long time for action on the federal level. Living in Washington, I know the process too well. We all must work on the local level to get our Counties to use a strict IPM program
When obtaining the careful history, for school age children you must involve the school health room in documenting temperature, obvious symptoms, where did the child spend time that day. Lung capacity. The school must help to document...the parents words are not good enough.
Cynthia, research on the effects on newborn infants of
other organophosphates beyond chlorpyrifos is just beginning. The
focus on chlorpyrifos is probably a reflection of its current
extensive use in the United States.
Pardon me for interrupting, but I wanted to advise the
chat administrator that this is happening: I am receiving private
messages from several people. however, the applet screens are blank
and I cannot read their messages. -- Dr. Landrigan.
Why is Dursban considered worse than the other organophosphates? Don't they all give reason for concern?
(Marcia Marks) We cannot wait for all the scientific data. There are less risky alternatives to be used now.
REVENTION is best.
The key to successful IPM is awareness. There is sometimes just as much resistance from uninformed parents as there is from administrators. Environmental Awareness programs must go hand
in hand with implementation of true IPM programs.
Cathryn, I do not know whether chlorpyrifos is worse than other organophosphates because comparative research on their
neurodevelopmental effects has not been undertaken. however, I do know that chlorpyrifos is used very extensively and therefore has become a focus of public health concern.
To the room: If you wish to speak with Dr.
Landrigan, please address him in the main room - not with a private window.
In our neighborhood, we are planning to canvass
neighbors each Spring asking them not to use any pesticides ,
explaining why and offering alternative information.
Marcia, I agree that prevention is best and that
implementation of Integrated Pest Management (IPM) programs is a very logical way to achieve prevention.
Dr. Landrigan, just close those private windows
if they interfere with the chat.> Thank you, Administrator.
Laura, you may be interested to know that in some cities and counties in the U.S., a homeowner or a landlord is now required to notify the neighbors 24 or 48 hours in advance of any commercial application of pesticides.
Many states have 'Pesticide Sensitive Individual Notification Programs'. Parents who suspect their children are reacting to pesticide exposures or who just wish not to have their children exposed - should get their children's names on these notification lists. This is a great place to start. Programs are usually run through the Department of Agriculture (at the State Level).
Dr. Landrigan, What got you interested in the effects of
What kinds of alternatives are offered in place of pesticide
Louis, my work as Chair of the National Academy of Sciences Committee on Pesticides in the Diets of Infants and Children.
The report of that Committee can be obtained from the National
Academy's Press, 2100 Constitution Avenue, Washington, DC.
test. Does Dursban affect a person's ability to detoxify other
chemicals and cause multiple chemical sensitivity?
Rachel, there is an extensive literature on Integrated
Pest Management (IPM). Approaches included within this broad heading of IPM are sealing up cracks and crevices that are conduits for
cockroaches and other pests, carefully cleaning up all food residues,
and using low toxicity pesticides. for further information, I suggest
you visit your library because this literature is really quite
Once a child is hyper-sensitive to pesticides, is there anyway to 'detox' them - or are they required to lead a restricted lifestyle of avoidance and isolation.
if one finds out about the use of this chemical in
ones school should the EPA or someone be contacted
Veronika, the best approach is prevention.
I would be interested in researching the low toxicity pesticides, as I have children.
IPM techniques have come a long way. We have two schools in our district that are practicing 'pesticide free'
IPM...there are others. IPM does work. (Marcia Marks) If anyone would like to see a contract
for strict IPM in Montgomery County MD government buildings (a county of almost a million) call Jeff Marks at 240-777-4251 (no relation)
Jeremy, the best approach is to work with local
legislators to secure passage of legislation that require school
authorities to notify parents in advance of pesticide application. For
example, last year the state legislature in Connecticut passed such a
law. For details on the Connecticut story, you may wish to contact Dr.
John Wargo at Yale University.
Dr. Landrigan. Dr. Furlong's research then is
profound. He has identified the pathway that both Dursban and diazinon follow. Both of these pesticides become the toxic oxone form of their parent chemical in the body as a result of P450 activation. Now that he has recognized that the oxone form of these pesticides is formed in the body, he can easily test other organophosphates. He has said until now, neither the EPA nor DOW knew that the oxone forms were activated in the body. Now they know.
Cynthia, I am not familiar with Dr. Furlong's research. Is it in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature?
To the room: We have about 10 minutes left, so besure to ask your questions now to give Dr. Landrigan time to answer
Considerable information on IPM in schools is available on the Univ. of Florida Web site @
Why is it taking the EPA so long to review the pesticides
even with so many years worth of back up suggesting their negative
To all, here are some citations for research that Irely on: Cambell C, et al. Chlorpyrifos interferes with celldevelopment in rat brain regions. Brain Research Bulletin 43:179-189,1997. Cosenza M, et al. Effects of chlorpyrifos on neuronaldevelopment in rat embryo midbrain micromass cultures. Veterinary &Human Toxicology 37:118-121, 1995. Eskenazi et al. Exposures of
children to organophosphate pesticides and their potential adverse health effects. Environmental Health Perspectives 107:409-419, 1999.
Why not ask for restricting all chlorinated organophosphates? One pesticide at a time will bring us to the next millennium - and industry will invent new poisons before we can get the old one restricted.
What is the EPA's position with respect to the
precautionary principle? It will take years to review each chemical
one at a time. We can't wait that long to protect our children.
Cathryn, EPA's regulatory delay reflects the fact that
there exists strongly opposing points of view, as I discussed
(Last note was from Marcia Dr. Landrigan Yes, it is. I don't know which literature because I'm not a scientist, but his works have been peer reviewed and published. He works directly with the EPA. I can send
you the packet that he so kindly sent to me. I was referred to him for my daughter by another scientist who was a speaker at a Rachel Carson symposium in Washington DC.
Administrator: Is there any way to print out this dialogue? And does the fact that I am on a Mac rather than a PC make a difference?
Cynthia, I appreciate your respect for Dr. Furlong, but if his work has not yet received the approval of his scientific peers, then with all due respect it would have to be considered preliminary. it is important to note that there is a world of difference between the thoroughly peer-reviewed biomedical literature and other printed reports.
I don't think there is a difference between a mac
or pc in this instance. I will publish a transcript of this chat this
afternoon - you can find it at: http://chat.enn.com/transcript.asp Or
you can email me at firstname.lastname@example.org and I will send you a
(Marcia Marks) Everyone needs to vote in all elections
-to get legislators who will care about future generations and speed
up the regulatory process.
Room: We have about 5 minutes left in the chat.
If you have any final thoughts or questions please ask or state them
Marcia, under the Food Quality Protection Act, EPA is
required to assess the effects of cumulative exposure to multiple
pesticides. This represents a new approach for EPA, and they are just
beginning to come to grips with it. how long do you think it takes to get well from pesticide poisoning?
Dr. Landrigan, is this new testing including testing on the
LRC, the time required to recover from pesticide
poisoning depends upon the pesticide involved, the dose, and the type
and the timing of the treatment provided. Please everyone get your US Senator and Representative to vote in favor of the School Environment Act of 1999 (s.1716)
Would like to commend Dr. Landrigan on his work.
that was the School Environment Protection Act of 1999 (s. 1716) - this is right to know and IPM
Thank you Dr. Landrigan for all you have done
Dr. Landrigan, I have MCS - I am 9 years old - I was exposed to
dursban and I wonder how long it will take to get over this?
Peter, "inert" ingredients in pesticide formulations are the chemicals in the mix other than the active pesticide ingredient. These "inerts" can include solvents, diesel fuel, and other toxic and noxious materials.
thank you. this was great & informative.
Ok everyone - great chat today - thanks for
coming. Dr. Landrigan, thank you very much for your time today and
good luck in your efforts.
(Marcia Marks) As Rachel Carson said it is the chemicals in the environment in partnership with radiation that cause
ill health. That was 38 years ago. Veronika and all others, you are most welcome. --
Philip Landrigan, MD How long will it take?
Dr. Landrigan I apologize if I used incorrect terminology. I believe his work has been thoroughly peer-reviewed.
Like I mentioned earlier, I will have a transcript published this afternoon.
Thanks for coming today. Cheers all.
Dr. Landrigan, again, I thank you for your time and hope to have you on again at a later date.
Thank you very much, Administrator. -- Philip
Copyright 2000 Environmental News Network
back to links page